A parent and prominent artist says he is “deeply offended” after a Victoria school board official suggested that Indigenous students may not benefit from music classes.
Carey Newman, Hayalthkin’geme, penned an open letter in response to a recent Greater Victoria School District (SD61) committee meeting that has since been co-signed by hundreds of supporters.
Newman — a former SD61 Indigenous Ad Hoc Committee member — wrote the letter after SD61 secretary treasurer Kim Morris suggested cutting music programs, to focus on literary initiatives for Indigenous students instead.
In the May 10 meeting during budget talks, Morris spoke about Indigenous graduation rates being below the provincial average in SD61.
“Will core band, strings or choir improve the Indigenous completion rates? Do Indigenous students participate in band?” she asked.
“The biggest impact we can make on Indigenous student success is literacy.”
Now, Newman and others are demanding a public apology from the school district. Newman also announced his resignation from SD61’s Indigenous Ad Hoc Committee, saying this is only the latest development in a long-deteriorating relationship between the district and Indigenous community.
“As an Indigenous musician and father of a child who recently developed a love for violin while taking elementary strings, I am deeply offended by the suggestion that Indigenous students don’t participate in music programming,” his letter states, in part.
“Implying that music cuts are needed to support Indigenous students is false, divisive, undermines the safety of all Indigenous students who attend school in SD61, and is the exact opposite of reconciliation.”
Newman is known as the creator of the Witness Blanket, a national monument to recognize the atrocities of residential schools.
He is Kwakwak’awakw through his father from the Kukwekum, Giiksam, and WaWalaby’ie clans of northern Vancouver Island, and Coast Salish from Cheam of the Sto:lo Nation along the upper Fraser Valley.
Newman says his concerns about SD61 began during a “debacle” in 2017, when he says Indigenous stakeholders’ recommendations went unheard, and the district hired a non-Indigenous District Principal of Indigenous Education.
His letter further points to a March 1 Education Policy and Directions Committee Meeting, where meeting chair and board trustee Ryan Painter noted that too many Songhees and Esquimalt Nations members were present — citing board bylaws.
Newman’s letter goes on to address a survey seeking public input to their budgeting process that posed questions that ranked basic human rights.
But it was the May 10 meeting that pushed Newman to speak out — calling it a particularly egregious example that highlights a profound lack of understanding about what reconciliation means. The budget still has cuts earmarked within Indigenous education.
“Taken together, this sequence of events reveals a pattern of systemic racism that can no longer be seen as a collection of unfortunate missteps, but rather as proof of deeply entrenched paternalistic attitudes towards Indigenous people and our education that continue to this day,” he writes.
Winona Waldron, the president of the Greater Victoria Teachers’ Association, shares Newman’s concerns, and wrote her own scathing letter on behalf of district teachers.
Waldron says concerns began on April 13, when SD61 announced a $7-million deficit — meaning cuts were on the way.
She says now, cutting the music program “under the guise of reconciliation” pits people against each other.
“The story we are being told is that the district needs to reinvent in Indigenous literacy and in that way will see better graduation rates for Indigenous students,” she tells IndigiNews in an interview.
“Somehow because we have music programs, that’s why our Indigenous youth are graduating at lower rates than their non-Indigenous peers and just that argument itself is a complete fallacy. There’s no evidence that one is connected to the other.”
The May 10 presentation did not provide data on the numbers of Indigenous students who do or do not participate in music, because the board said they do not keep track of that type of data after one of the board members requested it.
IndigiNews reached out to the school district but has not received a response.
Waldron says it’s problematic to “paint music as something that is for the elite.”
“There’s a lot of work to be done at the board office,” she says.